Janiel McEwan | Beyond the pews: Is Jamaica still a Christian nation?

Contributor

IT WAS a humid Sunday morning in Kingston, and the streets buzzed with the usual energy. Vendors hawked roasted peanuts and sugarcane near the church gates. Inside, the faint hum of an organ filled the air as a handful of congregants trickled in. The once-packed pews now had glaring gaps. Deacon Brown scanned the room, his weathered Bible clutched in hand. “There was a time,” he sighed, “when these benches overflowed with families. Now, even Easter Sunday feels ordinary.”

This moment is a microcosm of a much larger question: Is Jamaica, with its deep-rooted Christian traditions, still a Christian nation?

FAITH IN FLUX

For centuries, Christianity shaped Jamaica’s identity. From its colonial history with missionary schools to its spiritual anthems and Sunday rhythms, Christianity has been more than a religion – it has been a way of life. But today, the numbers tell a more complicated story.

In the 2011 census, 69 per cent of Jamaicans identified as Christian. Yet, a 2024 survey reveals a stark reality: only 30 per cent of Jamaicans attend church weekly, while 56 per cent seldom or never step inside a sanctuary. Perhaps more startling, over 20 per cent now claim no religious affiliation – a figure that’s been steadily climbing over the years.

The shift is not just numerical; it’s cultural. Younger generations, like 26-year-old Andre from Montego Bay, express their faith differently. “I believe in God, but the church isn’t my scene,” he says. “I feel closer to Him on a hike in the Blue Mountains than sitting through a three-hour sermon.”

FROM FAITHFUL TO ‘SPIRITUAL’

Andre’s sentiment mirrors a growing trend. Many Jamaicans still hold spiritual beliefs but reject the institution of the Church. Online sermons, prayer groups on WhatsApp, and YouTube devotionals are replacing Sunday services for some. For others, faith has become deeply personal, unbound by denominational labels.

This transition raises profound questions. Can a nation still call itself Christian when its people are abandoning traditional forms of worship? Is Jamaica’s Christianity defined by attendance, or does it lie in the values embedded in its culture?

A DIVERSE AND SHIFTING LANDSCAPE

Adding to the complexity is Jamaica’s growing religious diversity. Rastafarianism, once dismissed as fringe, is now a recognised and celebrated part of the national identity. Meanwhile, Muslims, Hindus, Baháʼís, and secular humanists are quietly carving out spaces in the Jamaican mosaic.

Take the annual Rastafari Rootzfest in Negril, where spirituality blends with culture, music, and a sense of liberation. Events like these challenge the notion that Christianity is the sole spiritual thread in Jamaica’s tapestry.

THE GLOBAL CONTEXT

Globally, Jamaica is not alone in this shift. Canada, once identified as a Christian country, no longer carries that label as a result of plummeting church attendance. The United States, with its megachurches and gospel fervour, is also seeing sharp declines in religious affiliation, especially among millennials and Gen Zs.

But Jamaica’s situation is unique. Unlike the secularism of Europe or the pluralism of North America, Jamaica’s Christian roots remain deeply embedded in its societal framework. From prayers before Parliament to gospel-infused reggae, faith is still woven into the nation’s DNA, even as practice wanes.

A CROSSROADS FOR THE NATION

So, what does this mean for Jamaica’s future? Some argue that the decline in formal religion signifies progress – a move toward individual freedom and away from rigid doctrines. Others see it as a loss of moral grounding, a drift from the community-centred values that once defined the island.

At the heart of this debate lies a more profound question: What does it mean to be a Christian nation in the 21st century? Is it about numbers, traditions, or values? And, if Jamaica is no longer a Christian nation, what will replace the guiding principles that shaped its past?

THE HOPEFUL PATH FORWARD

Deacon Brown, though saddened by the empty pews, remains hopeful. “Faith doesn’t disappear,” he says. “It transforms. Whether it’s a hymn in church or a prayer whispered on the bus, God is still here.”

And maybe he’s right. As Jamaica stands at this spiritual crossroads, one thing is clear: the island’s identity – Christian or not – will continue to evolve, shaped by the dynamic interplay of faith, culture, and the indomitable spirit of its people.

Send feedback to columns@gleanerjm.com and Janielmcewan17@gmail.com