Commentary November 20 2026

Kristen Gyles | Speaker selection warrants constitutional change

4 min read

Loading article...

  • Speaker of the House Juliet Holness.  Speaker of the House Juliet Holness. Photo - Rudolph Brown
  • Speaker of the House Juliet Holness.  Speaker of the House Juliet Holness. Photo - Rudolph Brown
  • Photo - File

Often when the concern is raised that the Speaker of the House is the wife of the prime minister, the rebuttal is that the Opposition supported the nomination of Mrs Holness for the role of Speaker.

The Opposition may be hypocritical for its criticism of Mrs Holness’ nomination now, given that it raised no objection to her nomination in 2020 when she was first nominated as Deputy Speaker. However, the Opposition’s hypocrisy is irrelevant to the actual issue, which is the inherent conflict of interest that arises from the Speaker of the House being a literal housemate to not only a sitting member of the House, but the prime minister himself. The fact is that, if Mrs Holness’ election to the role was improper, whether it is one person or 63 persons in Parliament who supported the decision, it is still improper.

Further, whatever position the Opposition takes on this issue matters very little, really. The Constitution, which creates the role of Speaker, does not specify how the Speaker is to be elected but, invariably, the Government will use its majority in the Lower House to select one of its own for the role.

With that said, the Government has folded its ears to the concerns of Jamaicans who have voiced apprehension about the election of a House Speaker who is married to the prime minister. No matter what explanation is given or what concerns are raised, the Government seems intent on forging ahead to do what suits itself, which undoubtedly would be to have a Speaker of the House who is closely connected with the prime minister.

The role of the Speaker of the House is to interpret and enforce the rules of the House as expressed in the Standing Orders and the Constitution. At any given sitting, this could mean granting permission to or withholding permission from a member who wishes to speak, tabling certain reports, moderating debates in the House, and so on. The Speaker holds a position of authority which, if abused, can either benefit or harm the sitting members of the House both individually and as a collective. Again, the prime minister is one of those sitting members.

As human beings, we have a tendency to view neutral and/or ambiguous situations in ways that confirm our existing beliefs. This is also true in relation to how we view people. When you like someone, it is easy to make excuses for them. You assume the best about them and their intentions, and you tend to downplay the mistakes they make, even if in very subtle ways. On the other hand, when you don’t like someone, you’re likely to see the worst in them and assume the worst about them. These are just human biases that we all suffer from, to varying extents.

It is a sign of sheer naivety and simple-mindedness to think that one can will himself or herself out of a natural and ingrained bias completely. The reason so many public and private sector organisations have rules that prohibit two or more relatives from working within the same department or unit is because this is a generally well-understood concept and a very basic governance consideration. It is normal to want to protect and look out for the people we have close connections to, and that can create real conflicts of interest in the workplace.

If faced with the choice, you would likely not fire your own spouse or take any action that could jeopardise their employment. Firstly, once an excuse can be found to justify or rationalise their suboptimal behaviour, you would be the one to find it. Secondly, where no justification can be found, you would probably be inclined to show mercy you would not show to a stranger. But, thirdly and even more significantly, it would not suit you to jeopardise your spouse’s employment, because their job loss would mean a loss of income for your household.

It is not hard to see how the same conflict between home life and work life could reasonably affect actions taken by the Speaker in relation to her husband. The concern about this conflict of interest is not an attack on the Speaker. She may be a very lovely lady with impeccable morals and values, but she is human.

The other issue, which is not specific to Mrs Holness, is the fact that, while the Speaker is expected (at least on paper) to be impartial, one can in no way claim impartiality when one is a political representative aligned to a specific party. Over the years, House Speakers have faced criticisms of biased rulings. This is nothing new, and such criticisms won’t go away until the basis for the selection of a House Speaker changes altogether.

In some Westminster-style parliaments, while the Speaker of the House is selected from the House of Representatives, the individual must immediately resign from their party in order to take up the role of Speaker. We can do even better than that. In a few jurisdictions, the applicable legislation actually allows for the Speaker of the House to be selected from outside the elected membership of the legislature. In other words, the Speaker of the House does not need to be an MP at all. The Speaker could very well be an independent member of the civil service appointed by the governor general. We have options.

Then again, we have been travelling on the ‘road to republic’ for some time now and are yet to reach our stop. So is it wishful thinking to even imagine that any constitutional change could come about soon?

Kristen Gyles is a free-thinking public affairs opinionator. Send feedback to kristengyles@gmail.com and columns@gleanerjm.com