Commentary November 18 2026

Editorial | Mottley’s ideas feasible

3 min read

Loading article...

Former Prime Minister P.J. Patterson with Barbados Prime Minister Mia Mottley at the launch of 'Caribbean Integration: The Patterson Doctrine', on Sunday at The University of the West Indies, Mona. Former Prime Minister P.J. Patterson with Barbados Prime Minister Mia Mottley at the launch of 'Caribbean Integration: The Patterson Doctrine', on Sunday at The University of the West Indies, Mona. Photo - Contributed

Mia Mottley’s proposal for a new system for funding the Caribbean Community (CARICOM), involving a portion of tariffs on third-country imports and a cess on tourists visiting the region, is feasible and practical and seemingly borrows from mechanisms employed by the European Union (EU).

At least, it is worthy of serious discussion.

However, The Gleaner’s Editorial Board would add to the Barbadian leader’s suggestion what has become its go-to idea for the sustainable financing of regional institutions, which has worked well for the Caribbean Court of Justice: the concept of a trust fund.

The board, of course, appreciates that a trust fund to meet the direct financing needs of the secretariat, which spent nearly EC$67 million in 2025, would perhaps require an outlay of seed, or investment, capital that regional governments may find unaffordable at this time. In that regard, a smaller, well-managed trust fund, with robust oversight, that generates decent surpluses could provide the Community with a financial cushion that can be called on in difficult times.

At the same time, in endorsing Ms Mottley’s suggestion, The Gleaner insists that changes to CARICOM’s financing mechanism must be accompanied by greater transparency in the secretariat’s financial reporting, beyond the publication of the assessed contributions of member states, as laid out in the Community’s annual reports.

Meanwhile, Prime Minister Mottley should expand and clarify her suggestion for a CARICOM “political head”, which reopens an old but necessary debate on the Community’s governance structure in a time of global turbulence.

financing proposal

Regarding the financing proposal, Ms Mottley, speaking in Kingston on Tuesday at the launch of a book examining the philosophical underpinnings of regionalism espoused by former Jamaica Prime Minister P.J. Patterson, noted that CARICOM’s annual budget is dependent on the assessed contributions of member states, which are then “voted through national budgets”. In other words, there are no automatic flows to the Community.

“The amounts are small; they are often paid late; and every payment, regrettably, is a fresh political decision,” Ms Mottley said. “You can’t run an organisation on that basis.”

She therefore suggested that 0.3 per cent of the tariffs on extra-regional imports into CARICOM should be earmarked for the Community and placed in specific CARICOM accounts by domestic customs agencies, rather than sent to national Consolidated Funds. Ms Mottley estimated that the tariff levy would generate between US$60 million and US$86 million, depending on how, and to what goods, it is applied. Additionally, she suggested a US$1 levy on cruise-ship passengers to the region and US$2 on long-stay visitors which, combined, would earn an estimated US$30 million. These two sources, Ms Mottley indicated, would cover the US$80 million to US$90 million CARICOM countries need annually to finance their basic operations.

absence of transparency

The assessment of members’ contributions to CARICOM’s budget is based on a not fully transparent matrix, whose major component is the size of a country’s economy. In 2025, Jamaica’s assessment was 18.77 per cent of the budget of EC$75.875 million, second to Trinidad and Tobago’s 22 per cent. Both countries had slightly smaller assessments than in the previous year. Barbados’ assessed contribution was 8.57 per cent of the budget.

While there has always been grumbling over who pays what to run CARICOM, the discord broke into the open earlier this year when Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar, in the midst of a row with CARICOM over political alignments and the legitimacy of the extension of the tenure of the current secretary-general, Karla Barnett, called for a review of her country’s contribution. She also threatened to withhold Trinidad and Tobago’s payments.

In a report a decade ago examining what should be the island’s future in CARICOM, a commission chaired by former Jamaica Prime Minister Bruce Golding highlighted “inadequate budget support” among the issues facing the community. It also noted the absence of transparency around its finances.

“The Commission is of the view that Member States’ obligations to the CARICOM budget must be given greater priority at the national level than is currently the case, and payments should be made on a timely basis so that the work of the various bodies can proceed on a predictable basis and without disruption,” the Golding Commission said.

In the EU, the Union is funded, in part, by a standardised levy of 0.3 per cent on each member’s VAT base (similar to Jamaica’s General Consumption Tax), with the taxable VAT base capped at 50 per cent of a country’s gross national income. Additionally, all tariffs on third-country imports into the EU theoretically belong to Brussels. However, member countries are allowed to keep 25 per cent of the proceeds to cover the cost of collection and as an incentive for efficiency.

Now that Ms Mottley has placed these issues back on CARICOM’s agenda, the door is open to an honest debate on the governance questions that have gone dormant in the Community.