Editorial | AI debate, transparency
Loading article...
Prime Minister Dr Andrew Holness’ announcement this week that the Government has approved a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with an unnamed party for the establishment of artificial intelligence facilities on the island reinforces the need for a transparent discussion on the development of an AI policy for Jamaica.
Further, even as Jamaica shapes its own AI initiatives, given the technology’s rapid advance and the potential risks that accompany its capacity for good, this should be done within the framework of harmonised regional policies on AI as contemplated by the Caribbean Community (CARICOM). In that regard, The Gleaner’s Editorial Board repeats its call in September for the technology minister, Andrew Wheatley, to instruct the Government’s AI task force not only to take these issues on board but also to begin open public hearings on what it believes should be Jamaica’s AI strategy.
Additionally, Dr Wheatley should table a Jamaica AI white paper in Parliament, which should be sent for review by a joint select committee of the House and the Senate. Interested stakeholders would be invited to make written or oral submissions to the committee. This process need not interfere with the work of the task force, whose first report in September 2024 made sweeping policy recommendations rather than setting out a programmatic plan of action for Jamaica’s AI development.
The report stated: “ For AI to thrive, a robust digital infrastructure is essential. Jamaica must modernise its ICT infrastructure, including high-speed Internet, data centres, and cloud-computing services, to support AI development and deployment.
“On the other hand, not all of these infrastructural components are simultaneously required for every AI innovation. Jamaica needs to be strategic in its priorities for funding these infrastructural components because the costs of energy and cloud usage can be crippling if not managed well. Additionally, access to high-quality data is a key component in building AI systems, and data management policies need to be established to address this.”
PM’s statement vague
In his AI remarks at Sunday’s annual delegates’ conference of the Jamaica Labour Party (JLP), Dr Holness was not specific about the types of infrastructure contemplated by the MOU except to indicate that the Government’s wish was for Jamaica “not only to be a consumer of the technology but to be a part of the creation of the technology”.
“That is something that your administration intends to pursue so that your children can have jobs in the new economy that is going to be created using artificial intelligence,” the prime minister said.
The vagueness of the prime minister’s statement has, understandably, raised questions about the Government’s plan and its practicability given the vast amount of resources that, as highlighted by the task force, can be demanded by modern, even medium-size, AI data centres.
For instance, industry analysts point out that today’s standard hyperscale data centres, established over large campuses where large numbers of network servers with power-hungry chips process, store, and distribute monumental amounts of digital information, typically require between 200 megawatts and 750 megawatts of electricity, running 24 hours a day, every day of the year.
They also require redundancy to limit the possibility of downtime. That is enough electricity to run between 160,000 and more than half a million American homes and substantially more in the Caribbean. Systems used to keep the servers and chips cool often require additional power and, depending on the technology employed, significant amounts of water.
economic feasibility
The latest trend, however, is towards even more powerful data centres that consume even more energy. These demands on resources have caused many communities in the United States and elsewhere in the world to oppose hosting the data centres required by hyperscale AI systems.
However, analysts point out that it is possible for a smaller country like Jamaica to establish smaller, say, 20MW-25MW, facilities to meet domestic computing demand and ensure data sovereignty. But there are questions about the economic feasibility of pursuing this route given the availability of lower-cost hubs in North America, existing and planned additional communications links between the two regions, and Jamaica’s domestic energy costs.
These are among the issues that require full and transparent discussion, which should start with
• Prime Minister Holness providing further and better particulars about the AI MOU.
• Dr Wheatley tabling an AI White Paper in Parliament.
• Hearings on the White Paper by a joint select committee of Parliament.
• Front-facing engagement with the public by the Government’s AI taskforce.