Fiscal fight
Loading article...
Finance and the Public Service Minister Fayval Williams says the decline in Brent crude prices on the international market is having a positive effect locally, with Petrojam’s ex-refinery price for E10 petrol falling over the last six weeks from $209.62 per litre in early October to $191.31 per litre as at November 12.
However, she said pressure on oil prices was not yet over, noting that retailers also set their own margins at the pumps.
Her remarks came during a parliamentary debate on suspending the fiscal rules until March 31, 2028, and setting the end of the 2031-32 fiscal year as the deadline for reducing public debt to 60 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) or less.
Williams said suspending the fiscal rules would give the Government room to rebuild the economy without breaching the law. However, she stressed that it was not a licence to abandon fiscal discipline.
She argued that Hurricane Melissa, the war in the Middle East and the recent drought had dealt significant blows to the Jamaican economy. But her Opposition counterpart, Julian Robinson, said poor management by the Government had compounded the economic woes facing the country.
The finance minister said the Middle East war had sent oil prices soaring to US$116 per barrel in late October, but noted that they were now trending downwards, to about US$92 per barrel.
She noted that not all Jamaicans had recovered from Melissa, including those whose homes were damaged. More than 118,000 households were assessed for assistance under the ROOFS programme, with nearly half receiving assistance to date, amounting to $12 billion.
Williams said $9.65 billion had been earmarked for the ROOFS programme in the First Supplementary Estimates, which were tabled in Parliament on Tuesday. She said the allocation would help the Government reach 90 per cent of the households assessed by the end of the year, with the remainder to be assisted by January 2027.
In his contribution to the debate, Robinson criticised the administration’s implementation of its $18-billion tax package.
Describing it as the worst implementation of a tax package he had ever seen, Robinson said the Environmental Protection Levy, announced in March, was only legislated last month, five months after its announcement.
He also said there was still no clarity about what the proposed tax on digital services would entail.
In March, the Government announced that it would collect $300 million by applying General Consumption Tax to digital services. The tax is expected to take effect in the fourth quarter of the current fiscal year, which runs from January to March 2027.
Robinson said the Opposition had also discovered that Airbnb and other short-term rentals would be taxed. He said the information was disclosed only after he asked a question in Parliament following a lengthy debate on the NaRRA legislation earlier this year.
“Nothing was said directly, enuh. It was a new tax measure but it wasn’t brought here in the way tax measures were. There is still no clarity on that,” Robinson said, adding that the Opposition had tabled questions for responses from the finance minister.
The Opposition spokesman on finance said he had warned the Government against imposing taxes on Jamaicans while the country was recovering from the devastating storm.
He said government revenue for the first six months was running $28 billion below projections.
“Even worse, the Government’s projected borrowing is $79 billion above their own forecast,” he said.
Robinson argued that if the economy was under significant strain, it was not prudent to try to extract more revenue from it through taxes.
He said that while Jamaica could not control developments in the Middle East, the country had the ability to generate its own energy supply.
“It has taken this Government eight years to put out a request for proposal for additional capacity in solar energy,” he said.
edmond.campbell@gleanerjm.com